Daly_2021.pdf (363.97 kB)
Making new meanings: the entextualisation of digital communications evidence in English sexual offences trials
journal contribution
posted on 2023-08-30, 19:02 authored by Ellen DalyThere have been growing concerns about the malleability of digital communications evidence and its potential to reinforce embedded rape myths and cultural narratives that undermine victim-survivors in sexual offences trials. There is however a paucity of research exploring this issue in practice, and none in England and Wales. This article therefore uses two case studies, drawn from court observation research in 2019, to explore how digital communications evidence is used in English sexual offences trials. In both case studies the prosecution argued that digital communications between defendant and victim-survivor constituted admissions of guilt; both defendants resisted this by providing alternative meanings to the well-known colloquial phrases within the messages. Through the process of entextualisation, defence counsel bolstered the meanings defendants attributed to digital communications by drawing upon elements of the ‘real rape’ myth and the deeply entrenched misconception that women routinely lie about rape. This analysis builds on the existing literature by demonstrating that the malleability of digital evidence extends even to seemingly unambiguous communications.
History
Refereed
- Yes
Volume
0Issue number
0Page range
0Publication title
Crime, Media, CultureISSN
1741-6604External DOI
Publisher
SAGEFile version
- Accepted version
Language
- eng